The fallacy of fairness is a cognitive distortion in which individuals believe that life should be inherently just.

For example, they expect that their efforts should be met with proportionate rewards, and any perceived deviation from this expectation is deemed unacceptable.

Believing in fairness can be a positive value that motivates us to strive for justice. It's when this belief becomes rigid and unyielding, leading to unrealistic expectations and reactions, that it can be considered a part of an unhelpful thinking style.

Context within Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)

In CBT, the fallacy of fairness is recognised as a common cognitive distortion that contributes to unhelpful thought patterns and mental distress.

It leads to feelings of entitlement, resentment, and disillusionment when life fails to meet unrealistic expectations of fairness. This distortion also fuels a sense of helplessness, hindering us from effectively coping with adversity.

It’s often addressed through cognitive restructuring techniques, where individuals learn to become aware of and reframe unhelpful thoughts and beliefs.

Illustrative Case Study Example

Emma, a 35-year-old marketing executive, found herself frequently grappling with feelings of resentment in both her personal and professional life. Despite working hard, she often felt overlooked and unfairly treated, leading to a pervasive sense of dissatisfaction in life, low mood, and irritability.

Background

Emma's belief in fairness stemmed from early experiences in her childhood. The importance of hard work and meritocracy was drilled into her by her father from a young age. Throughout her life, she had strived to embody these values, expecting that her efforts would be duly rewarded. However, Emma's rigid adherence to this belief system left her vulnerable to disillusionment when life failed to meet her lofty expectations.

Identifying the Fallacy of Fairness

Through therapy sessions, Emma's therapist helped her recognise the fallacy of fairness underlying her thought patterns.

They explored specific instances where Emma felt unjustly treated, unpacking the underlying beliefs driving her reactions. Emma came to realise that her rigid insistence on fairness was unrealistic and often led to feelings of resentment.

Cognitive Restructuring Techniques

With a newfound awareness of the fallacy of fairness, Emma and her therapist began implementing cognitive restructuring techniques to challenge and reframe her unhelpful beliefs. They engaged in the following strategies:

• Identifying cognitive distortions. Emma learned to identify cognitive distortions such as black-and-white thinking and overgeneralisation, which contributed to her belief in fairness. By recognising these patterns, she was able to step back and evaluate situations more objectively.
• Examining evidence. Emma and her therapist examined the evidence supporting Emma's beliefs about fairness. They explored alternative explanations for perceived injustices and considered factors beyond her control that influenced outcomes.
• Generating alternative thoughts. Emma practiced introducing alternative, more balanced thoughts when faced with situations that triggered her rigid belief in fairness.
• Practicing gratitude. Emma cultivated a practice of gratitude to shift her focus away from perceived injustices and towards appreciation for the positives in her life.

Over time, Emma's diligent practice of CBT techniques yielded significant improvements in her wellbeing. She became less preoccupied with notions of fairness and more accepting of life's inherent uncertainties.

The Importance of Balance While Pursuing Positive Change

People who adhere to the fallacy of fairness often find themselves driven to pursue positive change with strong determination. Their deep-seated belief in the inherent rightness of fairness compels them to advocate for a more equitable society.

Motivated by a profound sense of moral obligation, they tirelessly champion causes aimed at righting perceived wrongs.

This is highly admirable. It’s crucial to advocate for positive change wherever possible. However, it's also important to acknowledge that achieving social change is a long and challenging process that requires resilience, patience, and self-care.

Burnout, compassion fatigue and exhaustion can hinder our ability to effectively advocate for change and sustain our efforts over the long term.

By finding a balance between striving for change and accepting the limitations of your control, you can maintain your mental wellbeing while continuing to work towards a more just world. Despite the inherent unfairness of life, you can still make a positive difference and contribute to meaningful social change efforts.

Summary

Recognising and challenging the fallacy of fairness is essential for cultivating mental resilience.

By embracing the inherent uncertainty of life and letting go of rigid expectations of fairness, you can approach challenges with greater clarity, respond to setbacks with compassion for yourself and others, and maintain your wellbeing while continuing to make a positive impact.

Free Resources to Support Your Clients

New to our website? At The Wellness Society, we create practical, integrative mental health and wellbeing tools. Our tools are designed to save you time while helping your clients thrive.

Explore our Free Tools Library to access a wide variety of resources you can use in your practice today.